Smith Lake · Comparison
Smith Lake vs Lake Martin
Smith Lake vs Lake Martin: size, depth, clarity, shoreline, water levels, distance from Birmingham and nearby towns, compared side by side with no verdict.
By Camden Davis · Updated
Smith Lake and Lake Martin are the two Alabama lakes Birmingham residents compare most often. Both are Alabama Power reservoirs with clear water, wooded shorelines and strong lake cultures, and both are a reasonable drive from the city in opposite directions. But they are built on very different landscapes, and that shapes how each one feels.
This comparison sticks to facts and local context. It does not pick a winner; the right lake depends on what you want. Figures should be confirmed with Alabama Power. For more on Smith Lake, see the Smith Lake guide.
Side-by-side facts
| Smith Lake | Lake Martin | |
|---|---|---|
| River | Sipsey Fork of the Black Warrior | Tallapoosa |
| Dam completed | 1961 | 1926 |
| Operator | Alabama Power | Alabama Power |
| Approximate area | About 21,200 acres | About 44,000 acres |
| Maximum depth | About 264 feet | Shallower than Smith |
| Shoreline | Roughly 500 to 640 miles (measures vary) | Roughly 700 to 880 miles (measures vary) |
| Landscape | Sandstone canyons and bluffs | Rolling hills, granite outcrops |
| Counties | Walker, Winston, Cullman | Tallapoosa, Coosa, Elmore |
| Nearest towns | Jasper, Cullman, Double Springs | Alexander City, Dadeville |
| Direction from Birmingham | Northwest | Southeast |
Landscape and water
Smith Lake fills deep, narrow canyons in the Cumberland Plateau. The result is long, branching creek arms with steep sandstone bluffs, very deep water and notable clarity. See why Smith Lake is so clear.
Lake Martin spreads across the rolling Piedmont, with broader open water, many coves and islands, and granite outcrops along its shores.
Water levels
Both lakes are drawn down each fall and refilled each spring, but by different amounts on different schedules. Smith Lake drops from near 510 feet to near 496 feet. See Smith Lake water levels. Lake Martin's winter drawdown follows its own operating guide.
Getting there from Birmingham
- Smith Lake: northwest via I-22 toward Jasper, or north via I-65 toward Cullman. See driving to Smith Lake from Birmingham.
- Lake Martin: southeast via US 280 through the Highway 280 corridor, Chelsea and Sylacauga toward Alexander City and Dadeville.
Travel time to either depends heavily on your starting point and destination on the lake.
Towns and services
- Smith Lake: Jasper, Cullman and Double Springs provide hospitals, groceries and services; small communities such as Arley and Crane Hill sit near the water. See the Walker, Winston and Cullman county guides.
- Lake Martin: Alexander City and Dadeville are the main towns, with more lakeside commercial development in some areas.
Public lands and recreation
- Smith Lake: the Bankhead National Forest and Sipsey Wilderness border the upper lake, with Forest Service recreation areas and nearby waterfalls.
- Lake Martin: Wind Creek State Park on the lake's north end near Alexander City is a large state park with camping and lake access.
Fishing
- Smith Lake: spotted bass and striped bass, with trout in the tailwater below the dam. See the Smith Lake fishing guide.
- Lake Martin: largemouth bass, striped bass, crappie and bluegill.
Which fits you?
Rather than a verdict, consider these questions:
- Which direction do you already drive on weekends?
- Do you prefer narrow coves and bluffs, or broad open water?
- How much does proximity to a larger town matter?
- How will each lake's winter drawdown affect the way you plan to use it?
Related guides
- Things to do on Smith Lake
- Living in Birmingham vs living at Smith Lake
- The Shelby County guide for the US 280 route
Frequently asked questions
Which is bigger, Smith Lake or Lake Martin?
Lake Martin covers more surface area, roughly twice the acreage of Smith Lake. Smith Lake is much deeper, reaching about 264 feet near its dam.
Which lake is clearer, Smith Lake or Lake Martin?
Both are known for relatively clear water by Alabama standards. Smith Lake is especially known for its clarity, owing to its deep sandstone canyons and forested watershed. Clarity on both lakes varies by location and season.
Which lake is closer to Birmingham?
Both are roughly an hour to an hour and a half from Birmingham depending on the destination. Smith Lake is northwest via I-22 or I-65, and Lake Martin is southeast via US 280.
Do both lakes go down in winter?
Yes. Alabama Power lowers both lakes in the fall and refills them in spring. The amount and timing differ by lake; check Alabama Power's operating data for each.