Side-by-side comparison

Mountain Brook vs Homewood: Side-by-Side Comparison

Mountain Brook vs Homewood, AL compared: walkability, lot sizes, villages vs a downtown, commutes, parks, schools and data, side by side.

By Camden Davis · Updated

This comparison sticks to facts and local context. It does not rank either place; the right fit depends on what you are looking for.

Mountain Brook and Homewood are side-by-side Over the Mountain cities, both close to downtown and UAB. Homewood is compact and gridded, with a real downtown; Mountain Brook is hilly and wooded, with three small villages. This comparison sticks to facts with no verdict. See the Mountain Brook guide and the Homewood guide.

Quick comparison

Mountain BrookHomewood
2020 populationAbout 22,000About 26,000
Incorporated19421926
Commercial centersThree villagesDowntown, SoHo, Edgewood, West Homewood
TerrainHills, creek valleysValley floor, slopes at edges
LotsLarger, woodedSmaller, flatter near the center
Main roadsUS 280, Red Mountain ExpresswayI-65, US 31, Red Mountain Expressway
School systemMountain Brook City SchoolsHomewood City Schools

Location and commute

Both cities are minutes from UAB and Southside via the Red Mountain Expressway. Homewood also has I-65 along its west side; Mountain Brook has US 280 along its south side.

Character

  • Homewood: walkable downtown, gridded streets, Samford University, the Shades Creek Greenway.
  • Mountain Brook: wooded hills, older homes, village centers, the Jemison Trail.

Things to do and parks

Shades Creek connects the two: the Jemison Trail in Mountain Brook and the greenway in Homewood follow the same creek.

Schools

Each city runs its own system. This site does not rate or rank schools. See the Alabama State Department of Education report card site.

Data

Mountain BrookHomewood
Median sale priceData pending: Mountain Brook median sale price, source TBDData pending: Homewood median sale price, source TBD
Median rentData pending: Mountain Brook median rent, source TBDData pending: Homewood median rent, source TBD

Frequently asked questions

Which is more walkable, Mountain Brook or Homewood?

Homewood's downtown and Edgewood areas sit on flatter, gridded streets with more sidewalks, making them among the most walkable areas in the suburbs. Mountain Brook is walkable near its villages, but many streets are winding and lack sidewalks.

Are lots bigger in Mountain Brook or Homewood?

Lots in Mountain Brook tend to be larger and more wooded; Homewood's lots near downtown and Edgewood tend to be smaller and flatter.

Do Mountain Brook and Homewood share a school system?

No. Each city has its own school system.